Do you think of credit card points as currency? If you don’t, you’re missing out on some great deals and cool locations. Cindy Greenstein, The Points Mom, will give you some tips on how to take advantage of deals, points, offers, and travel in style without breaking the bank. More deals=more travel!
Travel Big, Pay Less, featuring The Points Mom
A Composition Chapter Series conversation with Cindy Greenstein
Meghan McCartan, Chief Marketing Officer, Composition Wealth
Cindy Greenstein, The Points Mom
---
MEGHAN: Hello, everyone. Welcome to another edition of our Composition Chapter series, where we talk to experts in their field about things related to money, but not exactly investments. I'm super psyched about this one because it's near and dear to my heart. We have Cindy Greenstein, The Points Mom. Why is it so near and dear? I love travel more than anything, and I am very cheap. I like to travel nicely, but I don't want to spend all my money.
Cindy is going to give us all the ins and outs of how to maximize points and get great deals, and tell us about some of her best vacations ever. Thank you for being here.
CINDY: Thank you for having me.
MEGHAN: Let's start at a really high level. If somebody takes away just three things about traveling on points, what should they be? What mistakes should they avoid? Let's do the top three first.
CINDY: I definitely have three top things.
Number one, make sure you are using credit cards that earn flexible rewards points. I know people love their airline miles and their Bonvoy points, but the easiest way to amass a lot of points and travel for free is to use cards that earn flexible rewards, like Amex Membership Rewards, Chase Ultimate Rewards, and Capital One miles, because you can transfer them to airlines and hotels.
Number two, pull the right card wherever you are. If you're at a grocery store, a restaurant, a gas station, getting a haircut, or buying a pair of sneakers, there is a right card for every purchase. We'll probably get into more of that.
The third thing is to try to make your plans early. The early bird really does get the worm when it comes to points and miles, so try to be early.
MEGHAN: That's really interesting, and I want to go back to your first point. If I'm platinum with a certain airline, it doesn't matter. It would be better to use something like the Amex Platinum and get the benefits that way. Am I saying that right?
CINDY: Right. I'm not singling out the Platinum, but any card that earns Membership Rewards, which your Platinum does earn. Generally speaking, I would rather have people put their spending on a card like that than on an airline or hotel card.
MEGHAN: Okay, got it.
CINDY: I'm sure we'll also get into why airline cards can be important.
MEGHAN: Let's talk about the elephant in the room. Should people carry a balance, or do you recommend paying off the balance every time, using cards for whatever you need and paying them off to avoid trouble?
CINDY: The minute you start to carry a balance and pay interest, and possibly fees, it negates the points and miles game. Unless you can pay your bills on time and in full, I don't recommend that anybody use credit cards at all. Use cash or your debit card until you're in a place where you can pay your bills on time and in full.
MEGHAN: That's what I tell my kids, too. It's the biggest lesson, because all of a sudden you're behind. I remember being $500 behind in college and thinking I was going to the poorhouse.
CINDY: Here's a tip for the kids. They're new to credit cards, and when they see their statement online, the payment due that's displayed is just the minimum payment due. A lot of kids, and maybe even some adults, see that number and pay it. Then the next month they're hit with interest. Credit cards make it a little tricky. You just have to know to pay your balance in full, not just the minimum payment due.
MEGHAN: That is a really good tip, because kids haven't done it before. They don't know, so they need to learn before they get behind.
I do have that Amex Platinum card, and it's getting more and more expensive. What fee would you say is worth it to have one of these flexible cards?
CINDY: It depends on the card. Your Amex Platinum has an $895 fee. It's worth it as long as you're availing yourself of the benefits that card gives you. You can make back more than $895 in a year. So there's not really a set amount. If your benefits outweigh your annual fee, then I think the fee is worth it.
But if the benefits don't outweigh it, or if you're not using them, and we all know ourselves and what we're going to do, then a fee, especially a big one, doesn't necessarily make sense.
MEGHAN: That leads to my next question. How do you keep track of all the benefits on each card? How do you avoid missing a discount or a credit one month?
CINDY: It's definitely not easy, and the more cards you have, the more benefits you have to remember. If you follow me on Instagram, I post reminders all the time, like "September 30th is coming, and you need to remember this." I do that monthly. Some people use spreadsheets, and there are programs out there. I even make one, called the Points Wallet. You input which cards you have, without any personal information, and if you work at it, you'll be able to see that a benefit is expiring on October 31st or that another one reset on July 1st. So there are tools out there, but you have to be on it and actually look at them.
MEGHAN: To make it work.
CINDY: Yes.
MEGHAN: This is a little like what you do. I'll see somebody post, "Right now, if you transfer 20,000 United points, you can get a first-class ticket on Lufthansa," or whatever it is. It always hurts my brain, and then I don't do it. Does the Points Wallet track those kinds of deals, and are they worth it?
CINDY: The Points Wallet doesn't track those, but there are a lot of other tools, and Instagrammers, and emails where you'll see them. There's a big caveat, though. Going back to my first tip, anyone you see who got one of those amazing deals was on it the day the flights opened.
It's possible to do. For example, you can use airline alliances: use your Virgin Atlantic miles and you're on the same plane as everybody on Delta, but you booked through Virgin Atlantic or Air France. Or you book United flights through Lufthansa or Aeroplan. But all of those people did it early, some of them a year in advance. Others did it very late, and sometimes the later you book, the better. But if you're looking for flights in the 6-to-9-month window, where most of us are, it's hard to get the crazy-good deals everyone posts about on TikTok. They're not easy.
MEGHAN: I don't know if this is your area, but I like to go places without spending a lot of money, and especially for Europe, I always think flying first class is part of the vacation. Is it better to use points to upgrade, or to use points to book the whole thing? Does it matter?
CINDY: It's not as easy anymore to use points to upgrade unless you get offers from the airline. I do recommend that once you book a flight, you check the airline's app often, because you might miss the email. Upgrades are also based on availability. If one is available, they'll make you the offer.
That means you'd book a lower fare and cross your fingers that you get an upgrade. If you know that you only want to go to Europe lying flat, I would just book that from the start and not rely on an upgrade, because who knows if it will even come.
MEGHAN: Right, and then you're sitting there wondering. Okay, let's make this fun. Hopefully the whole thing has been fun. Give us a couple of your best deals, some of the best things you've been able to do as the points master.
CINDY: First I'll give a little information about certain programs, because some programs offer better deals than others. Let me start with hotels. One of my favorite hotel programs for really good redemptions is Hyatt. So many of us have been Bonvoy loyalists forever, and there are so many Hilton loyalists out there, and Hyatt doesn't have as big a footprint. People tend not to think about it or remember it.
The thing about Hyatt is that it's the only hotel company that still has an award chart. Bonvoy and Hilton are based on supply and demand, so the number of points you redeem depends on how many people want the room. With Hyatt, you can go to a really nice Hyatt, and whatever you see on the chart is what you pay. Even if it's spring break or Christmas break, if it's available, that's what you pay.
Some of my best redemptions have been through Hyatt, including the Alila properties [confirm], like the one in Napa, a really high-end Hyatt. In places like that, I got rooms that would have been about $3,000 a night for around 55,000 points. I did that in Greece, too. Even a lot of the ski resorts, like the Park Hyatt Beaver Creek and the Cascade Village condos in Vail [confirm], are thousands and thousands of dollars, but they're only about 55,000 points a night. That's where I've gotten a lot of value in the past.
MEGHAN: That is so interesting. I have a friend who swears by Hyatt, too, because of the Andaz properties.
CINDY: Exactly.
MEGHAN: They have really amazing breakfast as part of it, too, not just a handful of Froot Loops that you walk out with.
CINDY: Right.
CINDY: In terms of airlines, probably my best one was Emirates to Greece, about three or four years ago. I was on it the day it opened, and I got the saver rate on points. I was able to transfer my Amex points to Emirates, and those flights were about $8,000 a person for me and my husband. We got them with about 250,000 Amex points. But again, I was on it the day it opened.
MEGHAN: Can you explain what you mean by "the day it opened"? When do airlines typically open a flight for booking?
CINDY: Domestic airlines like Delta and United open about 331 days in advance. Some international airlines open sooner. So if you know you want to go to Japan next October, I would start in the summer by seeing what's the furthest-out date you can book, and then figure out the day you'll need to get online for the dates you want next year. Every international airline is different, but in general it's about 330 to 360 days in advance.
MEGHAN: Okay, that's helpful. So Hyatt is an amazing tip. And the Emirates flight is something I want to do, too. It's one of my bucket list items. Was Greece on Emirates on your bucket list? What are some other bucket list items for you?
CINDY: I was only in business class. I wish I'd been in first class. One day I'd like to take a shower on a plane. I've never done that, and the content I'd get for my Instagram would be amazing.
Anything is available with points and miles, even an African safari, which we did, too. There are cards where you can use your points or miles to offset travel costs, instead of transferring them to an airline or hotel. You may not get the most value that way, but value is subjective. Not everybody needs to get three cents a point. Sometimes it's just nice to use points and not spend money.
Other bucket list items: I'd like to go to Australia, and I could possibly knock out a big chunk of that trip with my points and miles.
This is another tangent, but for anyone who has their own business, business expenses generate a lot of points and miles. My husband has his own law firm, so we're always very flush with points and miles. If you have a business, you can combine your business points and your personal points, so you can make a lot of bucket list things happen.
MEGHAN: I used to run conferences, and I would put a $40,000 bill on my card. Those were the days.
Okay, now a tip to take away. Something to avoid. Never, ever do this.
CINDY: My biggest "never" is this: don't ever be tricked into using your points at less than one cent each. When you check out on Amazon, it asks whether you want to use your Amex points or Chase points for the purchase, and you'll see it right in the checkout. They want you to do that because you're getting less than a cent per point, about seven-tenths of a cent. For a $100 purchase, you'd need to use about 130 Amex points, instead of at least 100 points for $100.
So don't ever use your points on Amazon, and don't ever use them for gift cards. That's another place where they get you. Even when you're checking out at somewhere like Bloomingdale's, and a lot of companies let you link your points, that's what you should avoid. I'd even go as far as to unlink your points from your Amazon account, because you can do that. It's something to be careful of.
MEGHAN: That's helpful. What have we not hit? When people come to you, what else do you want to make sure they know?
CINDY: Definitely get your family members involved. I call my family members "players." I got my kids cards under me and my husband when they were really young, so they could contribute to the family bucket of points and miles, especially when they were going out with friends, having dinner, or going to sporting events. That's why we always had a lot of points. We had five people working at it all at once. We even supported them when they were in college.
The other thing I want to say is that people are really hesitant to apply for cards. They think the more credit cards they have, the worse it is for their credit score. That's not true. When you apply for a credit card, your score does take a teeny ding. But ultimately, when you're approved, you get a credit line, and the bigger your credit line compared to how much you owe, the bigger a factor that is in your credit score, and it raises your score.
So for people who are hesitant to apply, know that you'll see a small decrease once you hit that apply button. But in one to two months, when everything shakes out and you have that credit available, your score will actually go up.
MEGHAN: And how many cards do you think people should have, in your expert view?
CINDY: This goes back to my first tip about having the right card for each purchase. I like people to have two to three. One card should cover your big categories, like dining, groceries, travel, and even transit like subways and trains, because there are a lot of cards that cover all of that. By "cover," I mean you're getting more than one point per dollar. You'll get two, three, or four points.
Then there's what I call "everything else" spending: you get your haircut, buy sneakers, buy things on Amazon, pay for your kid's soccer team, and whatever else. I don't love people earning just 1x on everything else, either. I want you to get more than 1x. So I love for people to have a multiplier card for dining, groceries, and necessities, and another card for everything else.
Then, as we touched on, there's the question of whether you should have an airline or hotel card. If status is important to you, and you realize, "Oh no, I'm not going to make my status this year with flying," then I like having an airline card to help with things like that, if that's important to you. So I'd say two to three, and be wonderful at those two to three.
MEGHAN: I have an airline card that's a Visa, because half the time you can't use an Amex here or there.
CINDY: That's a good point. I don't think anybody should have just Amex. You definitely need a Visa, too.
You said something to me at the beginning, and I think you're like so many other people I know who pull that Platinum card a lot for their spending. At least you're earning flexible rewards, not something tied to a loyalty program. But say you and I go to lunch, and the bill is $100, $50 for you and $50 for me. You put down your Amex Platinum, and I put down my Gold card. Do you know how many Amex points you're going to walk away with from lunch?
MEGHAN: Fifty.
CINDY: I'm getting 200. I'm getting four times what you're getting, because I'm getting 4x on dining with the Amex Gold card. Don't get me wrong, I love the Platinum. We talked about it in the beginning. I love it even though it's $895. I just don't love it for the spending. I love it for the benefits, but for your spending, I'd much rather see something else.
MEGHAN: Okay. Now, here's one mistake I made once. I was able to pay tuition on a credit card, and it was only an extra $20, no big deal, and I got a lot of points for that. But one time with tuition, the fee was something like 3%. That's bad, because then you're paying that much more, right?
CINDY: It's certainly bad with a card that only earns 1x per dollar. But if you have a card earning 2x per dollar, or even 1.5x, depending on the card, then we do a little calculation to see whether it's worth it, because all points have a value. Sometimes it can be worth paying a fee. But if you have a card that's only earning 1x, a 3% fee is never going to be worth it.
MEGHAN: Hearing you think of it as 1x, 2x, and so on helps me see where it makes sense and where it doesn't. Just knowing those things helps. Okay, one last amazing tip or story.
CINDY: I think we talked about this before: should people spend money just to earn points and miles that they don't need?
MEGHAN: Yes.
CINDY: My answer is no, except if they're going for a sign-up bonus and they aren't going to reach it. In that case, I don't mind if you buy yourself an Amazon gift card or a Sephora gift card. The worst thing you can do is apply for a card and not get the bonus, so that would be an exception.
Another exception is a card where, if you spend $30,000 a year, you get a free companion ticket or a statement credit. It goes back to keeping track and knowing where you are. Don't miss it by a little bit, like $500. If you're close to getting whatever the incentive is, just make sure you get it.
MEGHAN: That's the right way to think about it. I'm that much closer. I'll just go buy myself some jewelry or whatever.
Awesome. Well, I found this super helpful, so I'm sure everybody else will, too. I already follow you on Instagram, but everybody should, and we'll put that up so people can find you. It's been awesome. Where are you going next?
CINDY: We're going to Japan in November, and all the hotels are on points. I'm staying at the Park Hyatt in Tokyo and the Hotel Mitsui in Kyoto, which is not a Hyatt. It's a Bonvoy, but it's supposed to be amazing. That's also on points.
Speaking of which, since we talked a little about hotel programs: with Bonvoy and Hilton, when you book four nights on points, you get the fifth night free. That's something a little better than Hyatt, which doesn't give you the fifth night free. So we're getting the fifth night free at the Hotel Mitsui in Kyoto. I don't have much else planned. We just moved, so we're still figuring it out.
MEGHAN: Well, Japan is a pretty amazing plan to look forward to. Have an awesome time. Thank you so much, Cindy. I really appreciate it.
CINDY: Thank you.
---
Composition Wealth, LLC (“Composition Wealth”) is a registered investment adviser. Advisory services are offered only to clients or prospective clients where Composition Wealth and its representatives are properly licensed or exempt from licensure. This communication is for general informational purposes only and should not be considered investment, financial, tax, or legal advice. It should not be treated as a solicitation to buy or sell securities and does not consider individual investment objectives, strategies, tax status, or horizon. Please consult your own tax, legal and accounting advisors before making any related decisions.
To see a full list of our disclosures click here.